Proposed New Information Duties – Need for Limits

•

Share on:

The draft changes proposed in the consultation on the amendment to the Financial Market Infrastructure Act seek to introduce wide-ranging information duties towards the Disclosure Office or FINMA. The nemo tenetur principle and other basic principles of the rule of law, however, warrant specific limits.

By Benjamin Leisinger / Reto Ferrari-Visca (Reference: CapLaw-2024-84)

The draft legislation proposed by the Swiss Federal Council to amend the Financial Market Infrastructure Act (FMIA) includes several provisions, i.e., articles 39(7), 124b, 145 and 146 of the draft FMIA, that seek to introduce wide-ranging information duties towards the relevant Disclosure Office or the Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority FINMA (FINMA), respectively.

Article 39(7) of the draft revised FMIA would introduce a general duty for all participants admitted to a trading venue to provide FINMA with all the information and documents it requires to perform its duties. While this duty already applies – via article 29 of the Federal Act on the Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMASA) – to Swiss supervised entities, as the Explanatory Report on the Opening of the Consultation Procedure (Explanatory Report) correctly states, the new duty would apply to all participants of trading venues, irrespective of whether they are subject to supervision by FINMA.

Article 124b of the draft would introduce an explicit duty for individuals and companies subject to the disclosure and reporting obligations under the FMIA to provide the necessary information and documents to the relevant Disclosure Office. According to the Explanatory Report, such a right to information on the part of the Disclosure Offices is necessary so that they can actually assess whether a breach of the reporting obligation has occurred and thus be able to comply with their supervisory obligations regarding the correct fulfillment of the reporting obligation in accordance with article 124a. The Disclosure Offices are not required to conduct any actual investigations beyond the collection and evaluation of information as such investigations are reserved for FINMA as the competent supervisory authority. In other words, the Disclosure Offices only require the information and documents that are necessary to ensure that all disclosure obligations are fulfilled and that transparency within the financial market is maintained. 

Similarly, the new draft article 145 FMIA states that, amongst others, the supervisory instruments in accordance with article 29(1) FINMASA apply to all persons who violate certain articles of the revised FMIA (including the disclosure obligation in article 120 FMIA). Article 29 FINMASA is the legal basis for the duty to provide FINMA with all information and documents that it requires to carry out its tasks. 

Furthermore, article 146 of the draft legislation intends to introduce an information duty. According to the draft legislation, the admission, disclosure and monitoring bodies of the trading venues and DLT trading systems as well as issuers and their agents would have to provide FINMA all information and documents that it requires to fulfill its duties.

All of the proposed statutory rules to provide information have a common and significant defect: they can come into conflict with the fundamental principle that no one is obliged to incriminate themselves (so-called prohibition of self-incrimination or nemo tenetur se ipsum accusare principle). While wide-ranging information duties towards the Disclosure Offices and FINMA may arguably be in the public interest, in particular to ensure the proper functioning and transparency of the financial markets, and thus in general justified, they cannot override the nemo tenetur se ipsum accusare principle. This principle is guaranteed by both article 32 of the Federal Constitution of the Swiss Confederation and by international law (specifically, by article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights and article 14(3)g of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights) and applies to individuals and legal entities alike. Therefore, in the authors’ view, this conflict must be resolved by establishing an explicit statutory right of refusal, particularly given that the new information obligations are to apply to all participants of trading venues and/or to issuers and their agents. Relevant existing procedural regulations, for example, do provide for corresponding explicit rights of refusal (e.g. article 42 Federal Act on Federal Civil Procedure; article 16 Federal Act on Administrative Procedure; article 169 Swiss Criminal Procedure Code; article 163 Swiss Civil Procedure Code). The right of refusal must also extend to the case of possible danger to close persons. In this context, such persons must include, in particular, persons for whom the person or company obliged to provide information or a group company has a duty of care (such as employees and members of the board of directors). It is essential that the final draft of the legislation provides clarity on this matter to avoid any ambiguity or uncertainty. In line with fundamental legal principles on the rule of law, the final legislation should also clearly state that matters and documents that are subject to attorney-client privilege are not covered by the duty to provide information, also not where attorneys act as an agent of an issuer.

At the very least, a rule should be introduced that any information provided to the Disclosure Office or FINMA, as applicable, cannot be used in related proceedings that could lead to criminal or administrative sanctions. The European Court of Human Rights, for example, has on various occasions qualified the use of information obtained in administrative proceedings on the basis of a duty to provide information as inadmissible in criminal proceedings and thus ultimately established a ban on the use of such evidence.

The legislator should take note of the existing critical views voiced in connection with article 29 FINMASA and should carefully consider whether the same obligations should be introduced for all market participants in connection with regulations on market abuse and/or the notification of significant shareholdings.

Benjamin Leisinger (benjamin.leisinger@homburger.ch)
Reto Ferrari-Visca (reto.ferrari-visca@homburger.ch)

Discover more articles

We provide up-to-date information on legal and regulatory developments regarding the capital markets, publish concise articles on developments in the Swiss and international financial markets, and announce recent deals and forthcoming events.

  • FinSA Conduct Obligations: FINMA‘sRecent Enforcement Activity

    FINMA has intensified its enforcement of the conduct obligations governing individual financial services under the Financial Services Act (FinSA). The publicly communicated conclusions of two recent enforcement proceedings are good examples of interventions by the regulator under the FinSA conduct regime. Accompanied by FINMA Guidance 03/2026, which highlights recurring risk patterns, these cases signal that the conduct obligations are now firmly on FINMA‘s enforcement radar.


  • KAPITALMARKTRECHT IM FOKUS 2026 – CONFERENCE REPORT | 19 August 2026, SIX ConventionPoint, Zurich

    On 19 August 2026, practitioners, academics and market participants convened at SIX ConventionPoint in Zurich for Kapitalmarktrecht im Fokus 2026. Under the Title “Clarity or Room for Interpretation? Challenges in Interpreting Bond Terms and Conditions“ (Klarheit oder Auslegungsspielraum? Herausforderungen bei der Interpretation von Anleihensbedingungen), the conference examined how standardized bond terms should be interpreted, the interaction between contractual provisions and regulatory requirements and the significance of prospectuses, risk factors and changing market practice. Particular attention was paid to regulatory capital instruments and the Point of Non-Viability (PONV), against the background of the write-down of Credit Suisse AT1 instruments and the…


  • EHRA CLARIFIES REGISTRATION PRACTICE FOR CONDITIONAL CAPITAL WITHIN AND OUTSIDE THE CAPITAL BAND 

    In a practice note dated 27 August 2026, the Federal Commercial Register Office (EHRA) clarified the registration practice applicable where a company‘s articles of association provide for conditional capital both within a capital band and outside the capital band. This article sets out the resulting registration practice.


  • Swiss advisers subject to the Swiss Anti-Money Laundering Act: Scope and Duties

    Effective 1 October 2026, the revised Swiss Anti-Money Laundering Act will extend Switzerland‘s anti-money laundering framework to advisers participating professionally in covered transactions. Lawyers, notaries, fiduciaries, accountants, tax advisers, M&A advisers and other professionals may become subject to due-diligence, organizational and certain reporting requirements under the AML framework even if they do not execute financial transactions themselves. This article summarizes the new regime, its principal exemptions and its consequences for professional advisers.


  • The Impact of Article 21c CRD VI on Swiss Banks‘ Loan Portfolios

    Effective as of 11 January 2027, CRD VI introduces an EU-wide restriction on third-country institutions‘ cross-border lending activities. Under the new article 21c CRD VI, Swiss banks may no longer extend loans, provide guarantees, or make credit commitments to EU-domiciled borrowers without an authorized subsidiary or branch in the relevant member state. The prohibition covers all corporate finance activities with an EU nexus, including syndicated credit facilities.


  • DocMorris Finance B.V.‘s Issuance of CHF 96.8 Million Senior Guaranteed Convertible Bonds Due 2031 and Concurrent Repurchase of Outstanding Convertible Bonds Due 2028

    On 11 September 2026, DocMorris Finance B.V., a directly wholly-owned subsidiary of DocMorris AG (SIX: DOCM), successfully completed the private placement of CHF 96.8 million 1.5 per cent. senior unsecured convertible bonds due 16 March 2031, unconditionally and irrevocably guaranteed by DocMorris AG and convertible into existing and/or newly issued registered shares of DocMorris AG. Concurrently with the new issuance, DocMorris AG completed the full repurchase of its outstanding 3.0 per cent. convertible bonds due August 2028 with a nominal amount of CHF 49.6 million through privately negotiated bilateral transactions. The repurchased bonds will be cancelled. The transaction reduced the…